Reddit's most-named ad spy tool is the free Meta Ad Library, named in 18 of the 56 threads we read. The complaints we quote about paid tools are mostly about price, billing and support. Nobody in those threads has a way to see which competitor ad is winning, because no library shows performance.
Disclosure: we make a free Meta Ad Library downloader extension and sell ad-creative products, so we have a stake in this topic. We have not used the paid tools below for this page. Everything here comes from Reddit threads and from each vendor's public pages, read on 1 November 2026. How we research Reddit explains how we pick quotes and flag vendors.
Which ad spy tools does Reddit name?
Reddit names the Meta Ad Library in 18 of the 56 threads we read, more than any paid tool. Foreplay is next at 7 threads, then AdSpy and PowerAdSpy at 5 each. The counts include replies and vendor plugs, so a high count tells you how often a tool comes up. It doesn't tell you people like it.
- Tool — Mentions (base: 56 threads) — What people praise — What people complain about — Price, as shown to a US visitor on 1 Nov 2026
- Meta Ad Library — 18 threads, 34 mentions — u/yeramian55 in r/ecommerce, 2025: "it lets you search any brand and see every ad they are running right now" (link) — u/Able_Green9662 in r/DigitalMarketing, 2026: "none of those ad library platforms give the ad metrics." (link) — Free
- Google Ads Transparency Center (for YouTube ads) — 2 threads, 6 mentions — u/pxldev in r/ecommerce, 2024: "the Google transparency center is the equivalent of fb ads library." (link) — None from a non-vendor. The only criticism came from a vendor selling a YouTube ad tool. — Free, per the thread. We did not check Google's terms.
- Foreplay — 7 threads, 14 mentions — u/Justin_3486 in r/ecommerce, 2025: "it has tons of ads from successful brands already organized, way easier than trying to build your own collection from scratch" (link) — u/bluefernies in r/PPC, 2025: "Foreplay is another option but its pricey if you just need downloads" (link). The same comment also recommends a free downloader, AdScoop. — Basic $59 a month ($49 billed yearly), Workflow $175 ($149), Agency $459 ($389). 7-day trial, card required. 14-day money-back after the first charge, none on annual plans.
- Motion — 1 thread, about 8 mentions (the word also matches non-tool uses) — None from independent users. The one reply in its favour came from a Motion employee (u/trickysghost in r/FacebookAds, 2025, who disclosed it) who said Motion is "probably not a great fit" at a $3-4k monthly spend (link). — u/Serious_Parsley5813 in r/FacebookAds, 2025: "dont waste your money on something like motion, it's just a wrapper on facebook data." (link) — Starter $999 a month, for up to $50k monthly ad spend. Pro and Growth are "Let's chat". Trial terms not stated on the page.
- Superads — 1 thread, 10 mentions — u/Conscious-Bet7617 in r/FacebookAds, 2025: "at that ad spend level it will be free or $49 a month vs about $250 for Motion or Foreplay" (link). This is a price claim, not a review. — u/MiGHTyDuCK97 in r/FacebookAds, 2026: "superads worst customer support ever" (link) — Professional "starting at $125/mo", billed $1,500 yearly, up to $100k monthly ad spend. 14-day trial. The page shows no separate monthly price.
- AdSpy — 5 threads, 12 mentions (AdSpy and PowerAdSpy counted together) — u/SmaxWilliams in r/PPC, 2021: "Very useful to get the best performing ads by keywords." (link). Dated thread. — No clean AdSpy complaint. The loudest one is about a different product, PowerAdSpy: u/MelodicMousse8333 in r/PPC, 2023: "power ad spy mightve been the worst paid trial i've ever submitted myself to" (link) — The adspy.com homepage says "virtually unlimited usage for just $149 per month!" and calls it an "introductory offer". We found no pricing page.
There isn't much praise. For each tool the table shows the clearest positive and negative comment we found rather than a tally. Several cells are empty because the only positive voice was a vendor.
What do the price complaints look like?
Redditors complain about two things: what the paid tools cost next to what the free library already shows, and billing. Two of the price claims below are user reports we could not confirm. The third we checked on the vendor's own page.
- AdSpy costs $149 a month, according to a commenter on a 2021 thread who was also pushing a group-buy reseller (link). We read adspy.com on 1 November 2026, and its homepage shows $149 a month as an "introductory offer", so the figure still matches. We found no plan list or trial terms.
- Motion's price rise comes from a user talking to a Motion employee: "you guys had rhe creative strategist bootcamp for beginner creative strategists and then you raised the prices 3x…" (link). That was u/United-Instance8987 in r/FacebookAds in 2025. We cannot verify a price history, so treat "3x" as one person's claim. We can confirm that Starter was $999 a month on 1 November 2026.
- On Superads, users disagree with each other and with the pricing page. u/United-Instance8987 in r/FacebookAds, 2025, said "Superads is 150€/month…" (link), and u/Conscious-Bet7617 said it would be "free or $49 a month" (link). The pricing page we read shows $125 a month, billed as $1,500 yearly.
- The same Superads complaint also covers billing: "ended the trail but got billed" (link). It's one user's report, but it's a good reason to read the cancellation terms before you start any trial that asks for a card.
What do people with small budgets actually use?

At a few thousand dollars a month in spend, Reddit's answer is the free libraries first. In the one thread where a brand spending $3-4k a month asked which paid tool to buy, one reply was "just use facebook itself." (u/Serious_Parsley5813, link), and the Motion employee who replied said Motion is most valuable at higher spend.
The other threads agree. The Meta Ad Library lets you search any brand and see its live ads, and Google's Transparency Center does the same for YouTube and Search. Two limits come up:
- The paid tools show less outside the US. u/steven447 in r/FacebookAds, 2021: "Spy tools are often useless in countries outside the US." (link). The thread is old, but if you advertise in India or any other non-US market, check coverage in your own market during any trial.
- You still have to download and organise what you find. In a 2025 r/PPC thread (link), the OP wanted to present competitor videos to a client and said an Edge browser extension "used to work" for downloading them. Our own tool answers that question, below.
Our guide to seeing competitor ads on Meta, Google and LinkedIn walks through the free libraries step by step.
Which competitor ad is actually winning?
No Reddit thread we read has a reliable answer, because no ad library shows performance. u/Able_Green9662 asks it directly in r/DigitalMarketing, 2026: "How do you know which creative or ad of the competitor is performing?" (link). In the same thread, someone asked for an automatic tracker and got the reply "Google and Meta official tools" (u/pudkovah, link).
Longevity is the only concrete test anyone offers. If an ad has run for months, somebody keeps paying for it. In the threads we read, the clearest statement of that rule comes from the founder of a paid ad library (u/vox_nihili_ist in r/FacebookAds, 2025: "top-tier ads are the ones that ran for over six months" (link)), so treat it as a vendor's rule of thumb rather than evidence. Our own guide also calls longevity the best free signal, with one warning: an ad can run for months because nobody checked it.
Here is a practical version that uses only free tools:
- Pull the competitor's active ads from the library and note when each one started.
- Count how many near-identical variations they run. Lots of variations on one idea suggests they are testing around a winner.
- Use all of it as a lead for your own test. None of it is a result.
Where our free tool fits (we make this)
We make the free Meta Ads Downloader, a Chrome extension that adds a Download button to every card in the Meta Ad Library. It saves the image or the video (as an MP4) and records how long the ad has run since its start date, which is the longevity signal above. Instagram ads sit in the same library, so it covers those too.
It won't tell you which ads win, and it doesn't do YouTube. It's a research tool. The ads belong to the advertisers who made them, so use downloads to study structure, not to reuse their creative. Pair it with the free Meta Ad Library search builder to set country, platform and date filters once, the Instagram ads library guide for placement-specific research, and the ad library hub for Google and LinkedIn. We list it as a tool you can try, not as a pick over the others.
What we left out and why
Some names come up in threads but aren't in the table, for these reasons.
- MagicBrief has shut down. Its site shows a shutdown notice dated 31 July 2026 and sends users to Canva Grow.
- Minea is built for dropshipping product research, which is a different buyer from an ad creative team. Its Starter plan was $49 a month on 1 November 2026. We treat it as a mention only.
- Magritte came up through a vendor post: in 2025 a founder posted "I built a FREE library of 3,000+ high-performing ad creatives" in r/FacebookAds. A later commenter, u/ZenaMeTepe, wrote "It is no longer free." (link). We kept that thread out of the praise and complaint columns.
- Some replies in the threads above came from vendors: a YouTube ad tool's founder, and a Motion employee who disclosed it. We did not count either as user opinion.
How we checked

Mention counts come from the 56 Reddit threads in our research set (1,616 posts and comments), which we read on 1 November 2026. Prices come from each vendor's public page, checked the same day. Every quote is exact, under 25 words and linked. A quote is one person's report, not a statistic.
Your next step is to install the free Meta Ads Downloader and build your first swipe file from the ads you find. For a framework on what to do with them, start with the Creative Ads Course free chapter.
Sources
- r/FacebookAds, "Which creative analytics performance is best? Motion, Foreplay or Superads?", 2025-10-13: https://www.reddit.com/r/FacebookAds/comments/1o5rpta/which_creative_analytics_performance_is_best/
- r/ecommerce, "where do you find inspiration for ads?", 2025-11-27: https://www.reddit.com/r/ecommerce/comments/1p802n3/where_do_you_find_inspiration_for_ads/
- r/PPC, "How to Download Video from Ad Library of Facebook", 2025-06-13: https://www.reddit.com/r/PPC/comments/1lal4sy/how_to_download_video_from_ad_library_of_facebook/
- r/ecommerce, "Does Youtube Ads Have A "Library" Like Facebook ads do?", 2024-11-11: https://www.reddit.com/r/ecommerce/comments/1goaad7/does_youtube_ads_have_a_library_like_facebook_ads/
- r/DigitalMarketing, "Do you track competitor ads regularly? if so, what tool/service do you use?", 2026-05-14: https://www.reddit.com/r/DigitalMarketing/comments/1tciaws/do_you_track_competitor_ads_regularly_if_so_what/
- r/PPC, "Looking to get adspy - Worth it? any other alternatives you'd recommend?", 2021-06-14: https://www.reddit.com/r/PPC/comments/nz8hrq/looking_to_get_adspy_worth_it_any_other/
- r/PPC, "Is there any good ways to spy on competitors facebook ads and audience?", 2023-07-06: https://www.reddit.com/r/PPC/comments/14sev32/is_there_any_good_ways_to_spy_on_competitors/
- r/FacebookAds, "Free Ad Spy Tool", 2021-01-10: https://www.reddit.com/r/FacebookAds/comments/kugvdu/free_ad_spy_tool/
- r/FacebookAds, "I built a FREE library of 3,000+ high-performing ad creatives", 2025-02-17 (a vendor post, cited only as an example): https://www.reddit.com/r/FacebookAds/comments/1irjubd/i_built_a_free_library_of_3000_highperforming_ad/

The AI Ad-Making Kit
$99Make hyperreal AI video and image ads for any brand, with free AI tools. No camera, no agency.
- 10 modules
- 300+ hooks
- 500+ prompts
Canva ad templates, free.
Proven D2C ad layouts. Swap in your product, export, launch.
Browse templatesWant to act on what you just read?
Browse 3,400+ free, Canva-ready ad templates sorted by industry. One click to open, five minutes to customise.
Browse Free Templates










